[SC—AT VOTE—AGAINST] Commend Philosophers

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jinkies

Minister
-
-
-
TNP Nation
Vapid
Discord
solringen
sc.jpg

Commend Philosophers
Category: < Commend > | Target: Philosophers
Proposed by: THX1138 | Onsite Topic

The Security Council:

Establishing that Philosophers is the natural progression of Philosophy 115 [colloquially P115], born only of necessity, but sharing a common history, analogous culture, and hosting all P115’s former nations. As such, this commendation of Philosophers as successor also serves as symbolic commendation of P115, the historic cradle of its culture and accomplishments.

Recalling the formative days of this multiverse, and the establishment of Dr george, a distinctive nation with a culture combining theology, educational arts, and the highest proficiency in philosophy. Dr george brought all of this to bear in founding a region where others could “approach life rationally without unfounded assumptions.” This was Philosophy 115, the multiverse's first 'teaching region' specifically dedicated to understanding the intricacies and nuance of sentience. It quickly became home to over 200 nations.

Affirming that P115 distinguished itself as campus to higher thought and education. In its first decade, hundreds of nations under the direct tutelage of Dr george took residency in P115 via the 'extra credit' recruitment program. The region hosted myriad discussions, debates, and thought experiments, and promoted the causes of logic and reason. These activities were always hospitable to the nations of other regions, establishing P115 as welcoming cultural hub, and a place to flex intellectual muscle.

Admiring the maintenance in P115 of a tolerant platform in which to put philosophical theory into practice, both in national development and occasionally, in the execution of the Delegacy: Consider Ragaskan, who as Delegate engaged for over a year in an unwavering policy of 'radical centrism', voting 'no' as a default on every matter before the Assembly. This doctrinaire political position rooted in absurdist philosophy took the region on an entirely experimental tangent; but it was accepted in the spirit in which it was being conducted. Few regions would have permitted such a thing, but P115 stood apart.

Lauding P115 for inspiring other regions to incorporate an open debate and educational apparatus into their forums, where P115's nations could visit and engage in long form discussions 'off-campus'. Through this ebb and flow, P115 forged some of the longest lasting regional friendships in this realm. Alignment with like-minded regions including Forest, Anarchy, 10000 Islands, and Hell would eventually inspire and evolve into the embassy infrastructure we now take for granted, and the collegial society we enjoy today.

Noting that this collegial, inclusive tone was also reflected through P115's unique relationship with LGBTQ+ region Gay, where Dr. George’s alternate, Bearnation also served as elected founder and long-standing Delegate. P115 stood as proud ally at a time when the multiverse was less diverse, and often less tolerant. Further, Philosophy 115 spawned Philosophy 101, an entrée region for those new to philosophy and wishing to learn at beginner levels. P115 was also central to The Philosophy Consortium, gathering a variety of philosophy-based regions under one unifying banner.

Recognizing the stewardship of historic nations like Red Star of the West, Sunrise from the Sea, Central Kadigan, Kingdom of Cambria, Telgan, and Terra Amore, for sustaining P115 through a period of founder absence. The region stood as a model of cooperative proxy leadership until Dr George's return in 2020, inspiring a renaissance in P115. Regional population swelled to 400 nations. WA membership increased tenfold. Joint international events were planned, including groundwork laid for P115 to host a debate event as part of 10000 Island's inaugural Olympic games. Sadly, that momentum was thwarted when the founder fell finally inactive, imperiling the region, and making the exodus to Philosophers a heartbreaking necessity.

Acknowledging those steward nations for securing P115 for posterity, and, for coordinating the seamless passage of all natives to Philosophers, where safe, open borders can be maintained.

Appreciating Philosophers for preserving P115’s culture and for continuing to promote critical thinking, expression, and tolerance. Historic embassy partnerships established by P115 over a decade-and-a-half ago remain an intrinsic part of Philosophers’ continuing mission. The region is again engaging in international events and alliances. Commitment to growth has led to a new regional map created by MountAye. As in P115, international nations are always welcome to join in regional discussions, highlights of which are now shared with the world via newsletter.

Celebrating the approaching 20th anniversary of Philosophy 115, which now stands as secure monument to history, and, lauding the living continuation of all that was P115 in Philosophers - an equable place in the multiverse where any nation may still take a moment to ponder existence and wax philosophical.

Hereby commends Philosophers


Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations, NPA personnel, and those on NPA deployments will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote. If you are on an NPA deployment without being formally registered as an NPA member, name your deployed nation in your vote.

Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!

ForAgainstAbstainPresent
0700
 
Last edited:
Overview:
This proposal seeks to recognize and commend the region Philosophers for its contributions as a successor to Philosophy 115, emphasizing its commitment to promoting philosophical debate, education, and a welcoming community that has persisted for nearly two decades.

Recommendation:
While this proposal highlights the achievements of Philosophy 115 and its successor, Philosophers, this commendation lacks clarity in presenting a continuous, unified narrative of contributions that are commendable in their own right. Rather than showcasing sustained efforts or lasting regional impact, it instead compiles a series of disconnected deeds and contributions from individual nations. These, while notable in their own, do not amount to a level of impact that would justify recognition by the Security Council.

In addition to that, the commendation’s focus on philosophical discussions and cultural exchanges, while valuable, does not demonstrate a clear, measurable influence on the international community that would set Philosophers apart as uniquely commendable. The absence of significant, ongoing regional contributions further weakens the case, turning it into more of a tribute to past achievements rather than a reflection of meaningful, ongoing efforts.

For the above reasons, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote AGAINST the SC proposal at vote, "Commend Philosophers."

This IFV Recommendation was written by Brisdon in collaboration with the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs.
 
Last edited:
[Non-WA]

I'm not convinced this region is commendable, especially given the lack of effort put into continuity you'd like to see in a commendation of a community. None of the things listed would be commendable by themselves and putting them all together just elucidates to me how the entire proposal, while well-written, is effectively a house of cards.
 
Against

I agree with above a lot, I think that this is just a disconnected list of good deeds done by nations inside the region and later random things about its community that wouldn't actually be worth commending. Overall the justification just seems weak.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top