[SC - Defeated] - Recognition of the Borlands

Status
Not open for further replies.

Simone

Milky white thingy
-
-
-
-
Pronouns
It
TNP Nation
Simone_Republic
sc.jpg

Recognition of the Borlands
Category: Declaration | Type: Declare
Proposed by: United Fortnite Emirates | Onsite Topic


Article One: Introduction

The Borlandian Experiment was a clandestine operation conducted by a mysterious entity to determine which method of governance would create the most utopian society. Settlers were sent across the globe to establish nations based on vastly different ideals, and eventually created four nations to varying degrees of success. The tales of this gang of four will be chronicled below.

Article Two: East Borland

The first Borlandian nation to be founded was East Borland, a nation ruled by an iron-fist ruler who severely punished miscreants and strictly enforced law and order. Whilst the intentions behind East Borland was to establish a society where no one would be harmed by no-gooders, the nation ended up morphing into a totalitarian regime saturated in corruption and often acted antithetical to the tenets of this August Assembly.

In particular, East Borland’s totalitarian dictator His Supreme Eminence instituted many cruel and unusual edicts such as a prohibition on video games, exceeding the maximum permitted age and even biological reproduction, all done to further oppress their poor underlings. The nation also openly endorsed slavery, to the point where payment via trading slaves was legal tender. These policies infamously led to the World Census declaring the nation as the least hospitable for tourists, not that it mattered as no one was permitted to enter anyways.

Article Three: Northern Borland

Northern Borland was by far the most (in)famous of the Borlandian nations, with its five #1 rankings in World Census charts and repeated attempts by others to recognise them in the Security Council cementing a place for them in the history books. The nation’s tenets aimed to protect liberties at all costs, whether it was in taxation (its citizens were the freest from taxation) or in employment (its workforce was the 3rd-most utilised).

The governance of Northern Borland had mixed results. As its marvellously efficient economy was able to transform its pizza delivery, cheese exporting and beverage bottling industries into global titans, many people benefitted from high-quality food and drinks. However, they were so delectable that people often overconsumed them, leading to over 99% of Northern Borlandians being obese. The lack of regulations and lax stance on weapon ownership also led to a litany of violent crimes being committed in the nation on a daily basis.

Article Four: Deep South Borland

Deep South Borland was a sleeping giant of a nation, eschewing modern conveniences such as aircraft and computers in favour of a lifetime of devotion to its state religion, “The Trust Fairy Tale Ever Told”. The Deep South Borlandite government placed a strong emphasis on supporting its community through primitivism and isolationism.

Deep South Borland’s deep commitment to non-interventionism and non-violence made it one of the most pacifist and safest nations in the world at its peak. The rejection of the industrial revolution also maintained the country’s pristine environment, serving as a model for all other nations to follow. However, Deep South Borland did not come without significant flaws. In particular, the strict adherence to the state religion, enforced via threats of the death penalty, represented a gross violation of the freedom of belief. In addition, the nation’s ban on video games also trampled on the rights of innocent gamers.

Article Five: Tzo

Tzo, a nation which did not use the ‘Borland’ branding in order to dissociate itself from the troubles of its brethren, is not widely known as one of the nations in the Borlandian Experiment. Tzo was founded on the principles of inclusivity and providing for the disadvantaged, and was a dutiful member of this indomitable institution.

In terms of the Borlandian Experiment, Tzo certainly fulfilled its goal of establishing a utopia. Its extensive funding into public education and the preservation of artefacts created a populace that was the most cultured in the world. Its highly intelligent people also rejected irrational bigoted beliefs, creating an astonishingly inclusive and compassionate society that maintained high spirits at all times. It even exceeded some of its fellow Borlandians in certain categories, such as the beauty of its natural environment compared to Deep South Borland and compliance with the law compared to East Borland, proving it to be the greatest of the four.

Article Six: Conclusion

In spite of the end of the Borlandian Experiment and subsequent dissolution of its constituent members, its lasting legacy on international debates on governance and dominance of the statistical charts will not be easily forgotten. It is of utmost international importance that its impact be recognised via a declaration.

Thus, the Security Council hereby declares the Borlandian Experiment to be amongst the most masterfully executed delves into statistical and political research ever.
Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations, NPA personnel, and those on NPA deployments will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote. If you are on an NPA deployment without being formally registered as an NPA member, name your deployed nation in your vote.
Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!


ForAgainstAbstainPresent
7 1302
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Overview
This proposal seeks to declare and thus recognise the Gameplay dedication and statistical achievements of the Borlands, e.g. East Borland, Northern Borland, Tzo. That is to say, the author of the proposal believes the Borlands' astonishing statistical international rankings deserve to be periphrastically commended - in a roundabout way - via the Security Council's ability to express its opinion on international affairs, i.e. Declaration.

Recommendation
While the author - via the well-written proposal - makes a clever, compelling case for the recognition of the Borlands' international statistical achievements, the target of the resolution had publicly expressed their desire not to be recognised by the Security Council by way of a condemnation. The simple passage of time or a change in category does not change the fact that permission has not been given, especially when the target of the quasi-commendation remains absent - silence and absence in discourse by way of having ceased to exist.

For the above reasons, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote Against the Security Council proposal at vote, "Recognition Of The Borlands".
 
It feels like a backdoor commend, on the other hand since it's a declare, it can be seen as the author expressing their personal opinions, and declares can declare anything.

Edited vote to Against, I think the line "thus, the Security Council hereby declares the Borlandian Experiment to be amongst the most masterfully executed delves into statistical and political research ever" is exaggerating. An interesting experiment yes, "masterfully executed" when you can probably write a script off Trotterdam's data and execute 1000 card farms in different ways accordingly seems borderline.
 
Last edited:
I am slightly cautious about de facto commending someone who, due to no longer being active on the game, has not explicitly agreed thereto. However, due to the creativity of the use of the declaration, the quality of writing, and the impressiveness of Borlands’ collective achievements, I am overall in favour of the proposal.
 
For. I think creating four nations and spending time building each of them into four distinct entities with unique governments and impressive stat rankings is something worthy of recognition. I have only known Northern Borland via the rankings however.
 
Using declarations to essentially commend those who by circumstance are no longer commendable is an interesting dimension to them that I am a bit surprised we haven't seen before.

That being said, what exactly has changed since the last time this was attempted, but as a condemnation? Last time we were against as the target publicly expressed a desire not to be recognized by the SC. This is not a traditional badge but achieves the same result. I don't think the mere passage of time or the change in venue changes our position, considering the target continues to be CTE.

Against
 
Against. Waist of SC time to declare on what happened in nations as part of a “study”. Also, I disagree with the final clause as it commends a study within a declaration in essence.
 
An interesting experiment yes, "masterfully executed" when you can probably write a script off Trotterdam's data and execute 1000 card farms in different ways accordingly seems borderline.
That is obviously not the case. First of all, Trotterdam's data isn't always reliable to maximise statistics as it's just an aggregation of the max effect, min effect and standard deviation from every nation that answered that option. Also, given Northern Borland's consistency in answering issues over years, well before Trotterdam even started publishing such data, they definitely did not utilise this method to 'script' their issues answering.

the target of the resolution had publicly expressed their desire not to be recognised by the Security Council by way of a condemnation
The target also agreed to being commended via Commend Tzo by Eastern New England (which came after the supposed anti-condemnation statement was made) before, so the desire to not be C/C'd is not explicit at all. One Small Island also argues against this point much better than I could here -> https://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?p=39844754#p39844754
To twist that post into the sole reason to deny this declaration is a shortsighted decision.
 
I have zero recollection of Northern Borland saying he did not want a Condemnation. The main sticking point at the time was that NB did not express an opinion either way (nor, having retired already, was he able to).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top