[GA - Passed] Debtor Voting Rights

Discussion in 'WA Affairs' started by Sil Dorsett, Jan 14, 2019 at 1:41 AM.

  1. Sil Dorsett

    Sil Dorsett I'm a lot of things. Supporter Security Council Roleplay Moderator Vice Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,503
    TNP Nation:
    Sil Dorsett
    Discord:
    Sil Dorsett#5888
    [​IMG]
    Debtor Voting Rights

    Category: Furtherment of Democracy | Strength: Mild
    Proposed by: Imperium Anglorum | Onsite Topic
    Voting Instructions:
    • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
    • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
    • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
    • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
    Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!
     
  2. Sil Dorsett

    Sil Dorsett I'm a lot of things. Supporter Security Council Roleplay Moderator Vice Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,503
    TNP Nation:
    Sil Dorsett
    Discord:
    Sil Dorsett#5888
    [Reserved for IFV]
     
  3. Darcania

    Darcania Yatasal kul Seredrau Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    3,468
    TNP Nation:
    Darcania
    Discord:
    Zephyrkul#1089
  4. Wonderess

    Wonderess A lowly member of the faithful Supporter Citizen

    Messages:
    2,073
    TNP Nation:
    Castle Federation
    Discord:
    Wonderess #6213
  5. Sil Dorsett

    Sil Dorsett I'm a lot of things. Supporter Security Council Roleplay Moderator Vice Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,503
    TNP Nation:
    Sil Dorsett
    Discord:
    Sil Dorsett#5888
  6. Yuno

    Yuno TNPer Supporter NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    272
    TNP Nation:
    yuno owl
  7. BMWSurfer

    BMWSurfer Minister of Home Affairs Supporter Minister Election Commissioner NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    742
    TNP Nation:
    Veniyerris
    Discord:
    BMWSurfer#1965
    Too short!!!! against!!!

    Actually, For.
     
  8. Brendog

    Brendog An TNL lover Supporter Minister Election Commissioner NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    1,173
  9. Marcus Antonius

    Marcus Antonius Per Ardua Ad Astra Citizen

    Messages:
    6,076
    TNP Nation:
    Ethnon
    Discord:
    Marcus Antonius #8887
  10. Siwale

    Siwale TNPer Supporter Election Commissioner NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    6,914
    TNP Nation:
    Siwale
    Discord:
    Siwale #5057
    Per the Delegate’s request: Voting FOR
     
  11. Loh

    Loh TNPer Supporter Citizen

    Messages:
    1,095
    Discord:
    Loh#0058
    For...ish

    Changing my vote to against
     
    Last edited: Jan 14, 2019 at 10:13 AM
  12. St George

    St George Culture Doggo Supporter Roleplay Moderator Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    2,954
  13. Bobberino

    Bobberino NPA Colonel, DMoD/HA/Co Deputy Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    600
    TNP Nation:
    Bobberino
    Discord:
    Bobberino#9999
    The premise I'm for... But what a load of crap. Why are we letting something like this pass? I thought we voted against on resolutions that were too short or had bad grammar. Against
     
  14. Wilkshire

    Wilkshire Wise Elder Statesman Citizen

    Messages:
    22,188
    TNP Nation:
    Wilkshire
  15. Sanjurika

    Sanjurika Koala Fanatic Citizen

    Messages:
    568
    TNP Nation:
    Sanjurika
    Discord:
    Koala#3392
    For.

    My only complaint is that it's too long. My eyes hurt reading it.
     
  16. bowloftoast

    bowloftoast Not Just For Breakfast Deputy Minister Citizen

    Messages:
    135
    Discord:
    bowloftoast
    For...
    ...tentatively. My concern here is that this proposal will become one in a series, each attempting to limit a state's ability to suppress individual's rights to vote for every conceivable reason. Theoretically great, but with a cumulative effect of eventually making it impossible for nations to operate under dictatorship. While I am in full support of the most democratic possible forms of government for nations, it remains my belief that the WA should not be used as a hegemonic tool to make one (and only one) form of governance mandatory throughout the Assembly. I strongly feel that this cautionary caveat should be included in any IFV we generate.
     
  17. Artemis

    Artemis Oracler Speaker Security Council Election Commissioner Citizen

    Messages:
    589
    TNP Nation:
    Sundred
    Discord:
    Oracle#0851
  18. El Fiji Grande

    El Fiji Grande NBS Rocks! Supporter Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    3,649
    Discord:
    El Fiji Grande #3446
    It's short, which makes it controversial. I'm For. But based on previous voting tendencies, it really feels like there are a lot of hypocrites in the WA.
     
  19. Haor Chall

    Haor Chall IRC > Discord Citizen

    Messages:
    2,366
    TNP Nation:
    Haor Chall
  20. Pallaith

    Pallaith TNPer Security Council Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,579
    I count 12-4 so the vote is set to remain For.

    I find Toast’s input very interesting. I personally don’t thinking dictatorships are the best form of government. I believe certain things should be prevented or opposed as a general matter. The resolution is stopping a practice that I do not believe should exist, and if that is hard for dictatorships that’s a bonus for me, but ultimately not a concern for me since I’m concerned with the subject matter.

    There’s no grammar issue here Bob. The resolution is just short. That’s unusual for the WA, and for good reason. There aren’t many subjects that could be handled with such a straightforward approach without needing to consider other factors. Whenever a short one is proposed, it eventually becomes much longer after input and additional points are considered. I didn’t see that happen in the drafting of this resolution. Had I been there to try to extend the length, I honestly can’t think of what I would have added to it.

    What would you, or others concerned with length, have added? A preamble condemning the practice and giving a monologue? Is there a time when this practice is okay or an exception that was missed?

    Toast I will say that I share your concern to an extent. I don’t think there’s a lot of situations where this short resolution would work, and I’m not sure it’s something many people can pull off. I believe we are capable of drawing distinctions between these situations, we’ve done it before and we’ll do it again. If the resolution had merit, and I agree with its aim, I support it. The fact it is unusually short doesn’t change that for me, as long as it being short doesn’t interfere with its aims and sufficiently addressed the issue. If you guys don’t think it does that’s fine, but just because it’s short doesn’t necessarily mean it isn’t meeting that standard.

    And this is exactly why you guys should say more than just how you’re voting. A short resolution is particularly vulnerable to missing something, if I’m missing something let me know and I’ll reconsider my own take on the resolution.
     
  21. TlomzKrano

    TlomzKrano Just a blob chasing cars Minister Deputy Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    336
    Discord:
    Tlomz #1590
    The resolution assumes the right to vote in order for it to apply, if you have no elections or bar people in other ways... Then it really doesnt apply

    For
     
  22. Great Bights Mum

    Great Bights Mum Grande Dame Staff Member Administrator Supporter Security Council Citizen

    Messages:
    7,184
    Against. It's a bad resolution. How did something so poorly drafted get this far?
     
  23. Janus

    Janus Foreign Affairs Citizen

    Messages:
    599
    Much as I dislike agreeing with the above, I have to do so.
     
  24. Pallaith

    Pallaith TNPer Security Council Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,579
    How is it poorly drafted? Is your objection simply that it’s too short, or that it is too short because it’s missing key provisions? I don’t find the argument that resolutions must be a certain length to be a compelling one but I would be interested in exploring specific deficiencies this particular one may have.
     
  25. El Fiji Grande

    El Fiji Grande NBS Rocks! Supporter Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    3,649
    Discord:
    El Fiji Grande #3446
    I think the proposal is elegant in its brevity. It says no more than it intends to. More resolutions should be like this, and I do not think length should even factor in to an effort to repeal.
     
  26. Pallaith

    Pallaith TNPer Security Council Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,579
    Agreed, but with the caveat, already stated, that the short resolution better not give short shrift to an issue by virtue of being short. That’s where the length becomes important, and a crucial factor. In my judgment it isn’t the case here, and I am still waiting for those against to explain how I may be mistaken about that.
     
  27. A Chinese Propaganda Bot

    A Chinese Propaganda Bot New Arrival Citizen

    Messages:
    212
  28. Prydania

    Prydania Það er alltaf sólríkt í Beaconsviði Supporter Roleplay Moderator Citizen

    Messages:
    702
    Discord:
    LordGigaIce#7213
  29. Great Bights Mum

    Great Bights Mum Grande Dame Staff Member Administrator Supporter Security Council Citizen

    Messages:
    7,184
    There are no preambular clauses, and thus no justification as to why this particular resolution is needed. Is this a widespread problem? Do the voting requirements of individual member nations impact the global community? How so?
    It also assumes all nations conduct general elections, saying nothing of monarchies, dictatorships and the like. Or are they exempt? It does not make sense to say if you have a dictatorship, you'll be left alone, but should you decide to hold elections, the WA will be all up in your business.
     
  30. Panama Coalition

    Panama Coalition TNPer Citizen

    Messages:
    27
  31. Stoskavanya1

    Stoskavanya1 TNPer Resident Deputy Minister NPA

    Messages:
    188
    Aganist.

    The WA has never reconciled why countries that offer any sort of enfranchisement must conform to such standards, yet countries that offer no enfranchisement whatsoever are free to restrict political rights as they please.
     
  32. Pallaith

    Pallaith TNPer Security Council Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,579
    Updated count 15-7
     
  33. Pallaith

    Pallaith TNPer Security Council Delegate Citizen

    Messages:
    1,579
    Well that’s a much more coherent argument against that suggests some things were not properly considered. I’m still not big on the “bad for dictatorships” angle but I guess I get it. The argument does remind me a lot of the “this isn’t an international issue” one that comes up a lot. I’m not sure a preamble would have made a ton of difference in laying that out, but I can see why it had value in this case.
     
  34. El Fiji Grande

    El Fiji Grande NBS Rocks! Supporter Minister NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    3,649
    Discord:
    El Fiji Grande #3446
    I've been convinced - changing my vote to Against.
     
  35. New Bremerton

    New Bremerton Registered

    Messages:
    33
    For. In the wake of PtEoI, which was written to be deliberately misleading, and Preventing Financial Crises, which is written entirely in financialese, Imperium Anglorum has finally done the sensible thing and cut down massively on word count and indecipherable jargon. Kudos to him.

    IC: In our humble opinion, dictatorships and absolute monarchies have no place in the WA. If they don't like it, they can leave.
     
  36. KohGeek

    KohGeek Endotarter Citizen

    Messages:
    31
    Discord:
    KohGeek#4387
    Voting Against.

    The nation of Buckerino, despite upholding the sacrosanctity of democratic principle, believes that there are edge cases in which this resolution would fail to capture. The resolution fails to consider and clarify the cases where,

    a) the debtor is incarcerated for the sole reason of debt,
    b) the debtor has declared bankruptcy,
    c) the debtor fails to pay their taxes, and whether that falls another category of taxation crime

    and whether all the above are implicitly covered under this resolution.

    Hence, considering the facts above, the nation of Buckerino votes against this resolution unless a proper amendment is made later on.
     
  37. Syrixia

    Syrixia The one, the true, the great. Supporter Citizen

    Messages:
    11,916
    TNP Nation:
    Syrixia
    Discord:
    Syrixia#9338
  38. abc

    abc Duck NPA Citizen

    Messages:
    1,855
    Discord:
    abc#8265