[GA - DEFEATED] Removal Of Space Debris

Status
Not open for further replies.

Deropia

Peasant Wizard
-
Pronouns
He/Him
TNP Nation
Deropia
Discord
Dero#2736
ga.jpg

Removal Of Space Debris
Category: Environmental | Industry Affected: Affected: All Businesses - Mild
Proposed by: Magecastle Embassy Building A5, Co-authored by: Fhaengshia | Onsite Topic


The World Assembly,
Heralding
the efforts of "To Prevent Dangerous Debris" to prevent the creation of space debris,
Emphasising, however, that this remains silent on the active removal of space debris,
Identifying the harm that space debris can cause to both member nations and the environment alike _
  • Making space travel and exploration more difficult due to the risk of spacecraft colliding with space debris;
  • Greenhouse gases being created through atmospheric combustion of space debris;
  • The falling of space debris into the ground, which can cause property damage and harm sapient life;
  • Collisions between existing space debris generating further space debris;

Concerned by the ominous silence of World Assembly law in the topic of removal of space debris with the repeal of "Active Reduction of Space Debris", despite this topic necessitating a plan of action to protect member nations and their environments from space debris in collaboration between member nations and the World Assembly's institutions,
Enacts as follows _

  1. Space debris, in this resolution, means disused sapient-made items or parts thereof in outer space posing a cognisable risk of: entering, in the foreseeable future, volumes of atmosphere controlled by a member nation, or polluting these atmospheres through atmospheric burn-up; colliding with operating member nation spacecraft; or generating further space debris;

  2. The Debris In Space Committee (or DISC) of the WA Scientific Programme is to index -- in a manner accessible to member nations -- and work to develop technologies and strategies that remove space debris in such a manner minimising damage caused by use to the environment, property, and sapient populations but otherwise as efficiently and speedily as possible;

  3. All member nations that, in the view of the DISC, have sufficiently developed technology to do so with or without Section 3a or 3b assistance, are to regularly deploy Section 2 techniques in a manner determined by the DISC to minimise damage caused by use to the environment, property, and sapient populations but otherwise function as efficiently and speedily as possible;
    1. The WA General Fund is to subsidise deployment of Section 2 techniques by a member nation, on request by that member nation, sufficiently to avoid severe burden on that member nation's finances posed by deployment of these techniques, where the need for funding did not arise due to deliberate diversion of existing funds by that nation;

    2. The DISC is to assist member nations in deploying Section 2 techniques, where such assistance is necessary for that member nation to be able to deploy space debris removal techniques so as to comply with Section 2;

  4. The DISC is to provide pecuniary incentives through the WA General Fund to any entities that discover and provide to the DISC data, process, or research -- barring that classified for national security or personal privacy -- that would materially assist the DISC in developing, indexing, or coordinating Section 3 deployment of, Section 2 techniques; these incentives are to be proportionate to the utility of this information to the DISC, but sufficient to reasonably procure provision of such information in the view of the DISC;

  5. Each member nation is to refrain from obstructing any Section 3 removal efforts, and is to penalise any legal entity under its jurisdiction that does so, so as to reasonably deter similar attempts to obstruct these space debris removal efforts;

  6. Subject to Section 5, no part of this resolution is to be interpreted as regulating or restricting any space debris removal efforts conducted separately to Section 3 efforts.

Co-author: Fhaengshia
Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations and NPA personnel will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote.
Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!


ForAgainstAbstainPresent
61000
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Overview:

This proposal seeks to further address the issue of space debris beyond the scope of GAR#349, "To Prevent Dangerous Debris". It sets out to do this by establishing a subcommittee of the WA Scientific Programme known as the Debris In Space Committee (DISC), which is tasked with identifying and aiding in the development of technologies and techniques to mitigate and eliminate space debris. DISC is further tasked with directing member states that have developed suitable means of combating space debris to employ said techniques in a manner that would minimize collateral damage. It enables the use of the WA General Fund to incentivize the creation and handing over of methods and techniques of space debris mitigation. Lastly, it bars member states from interfering with space debris mitigation efforts, and empowers member nations to penalize any entity within its jurisdiction that does so.

Recommendation:

The Ministry of World Assembly Affairs, having reviewed the text of this proposal, finds its goals admirable. However, the proposal seems to fail to take into account a nation's culpability in the clean-up efforts, instead requiring nations to deploy such technology purely based on the nation's ability. Furthermore, the proposal fails to recognise the culpability of non-WA member states, instead forcing all member states to play the role of cleaning up after the mess made by all nations of the multiverse, with the use of the WA General Fund which is contributed to solely by member states.

For these reasons, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote AGAINST this proposal.

This IFV Recommendation was written in collaboration with our World Assembly Legislative League partners
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top