[GA - ILLEGAL] Crime Victims' Rights Act

Status
Not open for further replies.

Caius

dude
-
-
-
Pronouns
He/Him
TNP Nation
United States of Dictators
Discord
cayyus
ga.jpg

Crime Victims' Rights Act
Category: Civil Rights | Strength: Significant
Proposed by: Chipoli | Onsite Topic


The World Assembly,

Assured that crime victims play a valuable part in the criminal justice system;

Acknowledging that a resolution regarding the rights of crime victims was passed in the past that is no longer in effect;

Determined to give crime victims the justice they deserve, along with the respect, civility, and fair treatment that they merit;

Urging that the correct proceedings should be conducted during trial to certify that the rights of crime victims and the rights of the accused maintain a fair balance;

Defines the following terms necessary for this proposal:

  • “crime victim” as a person in a criminal prosecution who has presumably or allegedly been harmed in an emotional, physical, sexual, or financial manner or has been threatened to be harmed as a result of the criminal misconduct of another who is not simultaneously accused of another crime that occurred as a result from the same occurrence or incident.
  • “the accused” as a person who has been formally charged with a crime based on evidence that they have recently committed a criminal offense against the crime victim in a related case.
  • “critical stage of the prosecution” as any date or event in which a vital or jurisdictional component of the case is resolved or decided, including release hearings, hearings related to the trial’s scheduling, preliminary hearings, plea hearings, parole and probation hearings, trials, sentencing's, and other events deemed critical in the national justice system in question.

Commissions that member nations will provide their crime victims with the following rights:

1. Rights to be reasonably protected from the accused, including but not limited to:

a. The right to be tested for serious illnesses the crime victim may have been exposed to during the act of the crime.
b. The accused or any associates may not harass, stalk, harm, or threaten the victim.
c. The accused may not directly contact the victim without the presence of law enforcement unless the victim consents to the contact.
d. In certain cases, the court may grant protective orders to limit the disclosure of the crime victim's personal information, including through the process of filing under seal.

Additionally,

2. Crime Victims shall be allowed to hear any important events during the critical stage of the prosecution unless the crime victim requests otherwise.
3. Crime victims can exercise their rights personally, through an attorney, or a personal representative. In the case of a crime victim who is under the age of majority, incompetent, incapacitated, or deceased, the legal guardians of the crime victim, family members, or any other persons appointed as suitable by the court, may assume the crime victim's rights.
4. If any property is lost, crime victims have the right to full and timely restitution from the accused (if convicted) through the process of civil matters until the end of the prescriptive period.
5. Crime victims have the right to be referred to services that support victims and have them tailored to their needs.

Establishing that member nations will allow crime victims to exercise the rights stated above in the name of civility and justice.
Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations and NPA personnel will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote.
Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!


ForAgainstAbstainPresent
4600
 
Last edited by a moderator:
IFV

Overview
The Crime Victim Rights Act would require member nations to enact a set of rights aimed at protecting the victims of crime from the accused while encouraging their participation in the criminal justice system.

Recommendation
Though the Crime Victim Rights Act contains rights that the Ministry would like to see legislated on by the General Assembly, the Ministry notes a number of critical flaws in the resolution. These include the problematic definition of "Crime Victim" which would disqualify anyone alleged to have committed a crime stemming from the same incident, regardless of how frivolous the accusation may be. This allows criminals to circumvent the protections laid out with an unfounded accusation.

Furthermore, the resolution fails to define a number of terms that are necessary to the functionality of this resolution, such as the qualifying terms for those permitted to assume these rights in the victims stead.

For these reasons, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends voting against the resolution.

Our Voting Recommendation Dispatch—Please Upvote!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Apologies if this is completely incoherent. I'm very sleep-deprived atm:

Against (non-WA)

While the heart is there, this proposal struggles from a number of critical flaws and gaffs. In the hopes of saving time, I'll only give a few examples. Right in the first real line, it says: "Assured that crime victims play a valuable part in the criminal justice system;", when very few crime victims become involved in the process of criminal justice, and should absolutely retain the right not to do so if it could cause them any sort of stress; the definition of "“crime victim” as a person in a criminal prosecution who has presumably or allegedly been harmed in an emotional, physical, sexual, or financial manner or has been threatened to be harmed as a result of the criminal misconduct of another who is not simultaneously accused of another crime that occurred as a result from the same occurrence or incident." inherently excluding victims from being classified as such if they are accused, whether credible or not, of a crime, even insignificant, resulting of the same event, providing a clear and apparent loophole through which truly malicious criminals could circumvent the proposal's provisions; and Clause 3's allowance of the guardians, family members, or appointees of crime victims to assume their rights and privileges should the victim be "under the age of majority, incompetent, incapacitated, or deceased", despite not defining any of the qualifying terms, and with half having a wide variety of potential interpretations. There's more too, this is certainly not something we should support.
 
Moderation has ruled this proposal illegal and it will be discarded at the end of the voting period. Accordingly, thread locked. If this proposal is resubmitted and ruled legal or ruled legal later, the thread will be reopened.

The Ministry would like to thank all those who participated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top