[GA - At Vote] Repeal: "Prohibit Private Prisons"

[Bobberino]

Repeal: "Prohibit Private Prisons"
Category: Repeal | GA #468
Proposed by: Marxist Germany | Onsite Topic​

General Assembly Resolution #468 “Prohibit Private Prisons” (Category: Social Justice; Strength: Mild) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The World Assembly,

Applauding the efforts of this assembly to improve the standards and conditions of incarceration by prohibiting private prisons in the aforementioned resolution;

Quoting clause 2 which states "Further defines a "private prison" as a prison that is entirely owned and operated or primarily owned and operated by a nongovernmental corporation, a private individual, or any other private actor or actors";

Noting that the aforementioned clause states that a prison can only be considered private if it is wholly or primarily owned by a private proprietor;

Recognising that this therefore means governments can exploit this loophole through purchasing 51% of a private prison to avoid the ban;

Further Noting that a government can own a prison and lease it to a private proprietor as the resolution does not prohibit this;

Further Quoting clause 3 which states "Requires all member states and their political subdivisions, within two calendar years of this resolution's passage and in perpetuity thereafter, to discontinue their use of private prisons for the incarceration of individuals convicted of crimes and serving criminal sentences";

Observing that the aforementioned clause does not ban private prisons in member states but instead, allows them to operate as long as they receive criminals convicted in foreign non-member countries;

Discerning that member states can arrest individuals and place them in private prisons whilst they await their trial due to the aforementioned clause stating "discontinue their use of private prisons for the incarceration of individuals convicted of crimes and serving criminal sentences";

Concerned that the resolution does not prohibit private prisons in member states but only bars member states from incarcerating their own convicts in them;

Believing that this resolution ought to be repealed and replaced by a resolution that regulates private prisons, or prohibits them properly;

Hereby,

Repeals GA#468 "Prohibit Private Prisons".

Voting Instructions:

• Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
• Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
• Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
• Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.

Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!

 

[Bobberino]

eye eff vee

 

[Gorundu]

For

It's a sensible repeal based on the flaws of the target resolution that undermined its effectiveness, the same flaws for which we opposed it. I know some of you don't like the author very much, but I hope we can put aside our differences for what I think is a good repeal effort.

 

[TlomzKrano]

For

 

[mcmasterdonia]

For

 

[El Fiji Grande]

Voting For

 

[Rocketdog]

For

 

[Fregerson]

For, since it adequately address some concerns we had about the original bill

 

[Panama Coalition]

For

 

[Wilkshire]

Aganst

 

[Siwale]

For

 

[Kappacon]

For