[GA] Repeal "World Space Administration" [Complete]

Separatist Peoples

Separatist Peoples

TNPer
Repeal "World Space Administration"

A resolution to repeal previously passed legislation.


Category: Repeal

Resolution: GA#336

Proposed by: Tinfect

Description: WA General Assembly Resolution #336: World Space Administration (Category: Education and Creativity; Area of Effect: Educational) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

Argument: The World Assembly

Noting that the target Resolution was drafted in an attempt to promote space travel by Member States,

Recognizing that the Resolution not only fails in this goal, but also harms existing space programs of Member States,

Objecting to the Resolution's claim that Member Nations need cooperate in order to explore space, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary,

Concerned that with the inclusion of clauses that give the W.S.A authority to regulate the Interstellar and Interplanetary exploration of Member States, the Resolution cripples the ability of Member States to conduct their own Space Programmes,

Further Concerned that while the Resolution authorizes the W.S.A to regulate the Space Programmes of Member States, it fails to specify any regulations,

Extremely Confused by the Resolution's use of "Preformed", which makes many of the goals stated within the resolution impossible,

Noting that the Resolution demands that Member States disallow the use of vessels in a state of disrepair, without exception regarding vessels damaged in space or other unavoidable circumstances,

Further noting that the target Resolution contains numerous grammatical errors, which hinder comprehension of the Resolution,

Hereby Repeals General Assembly Resolution # 336, World Space Administration.
Click to expand...

For, Against, or Abstain
 
Ministry Determination
Vote Recommendation: FOR

This repeal is one that has been long in coming. It accurately sums up the myriad of issues with the WSA, not the least of which is that the current definition of travel in the cosmos covers literally all travel, space or terrestrial, within all WA members. That means, based on the strict manner in which GA resolutions are enforced, that the WSA can regulate whether an individual can walk from their bedroom to their bathroom.

What’s more, the WSA represents a massive moneysink, and promises nations free spacecraft and unending support in a space program. While international cooperation in space development is desirable, a system that essentially socializes all development on an international scale is not only ludicrous, it is a bankrupting force.
Finally, the World Space Administration has gone from a proposal to an active region. This is not, in and of itself, a problem, except that the WSA region promises voters the ability to change the WSA resolution through non-GA roleplaying. This is, of course, against the rules, and serves only to mislead and confuse the voter base into believing something that is simply factually incorrect.

In light of all the serious shortcomings and problems that this resolution has, it is small wonder that this repeal comes as a breath of fresh air. It is the determination of the World Assembly Ministry that it is in the best interest of The North Pacific, and even the whole World Assembly, to vote FOR this repeal.
 
Democratic Donkeys:
Against.
Click to expand...
Not voting, but I would have to agree. This repeal has turned into the "bash Bitely hour" and has become very sickening. I do hope Ele takes a stance against the witch hunt and votes against this just to prove a point.
 
Against.
I'm also against the resolution but the motion to repeal and the accompanying campaign are worse. When it comes to it I'll vote for a decent motion to repeal.
 
Wolfstar:
Democratic Donkeys:
Against.
Click to expand...
Not voting, but I would have to agree. This repeal has turned into the "bash Bitely hour" and has become very sickening. I do hope Ele takes a stance against the witch hunt and votes against this just to prove a point.
Click to expand...
Ummm. Bitely drafted a bad piece of legislation, then spent a lot of money to ensure the bill passed, then tried it again when the repeal came up and then was found to have broken multiple rules for NS and got booted from the WA?

I think it's perfectly understandable to "bash Bitely" given the behaviour.


And vote for the repeal btw
 
New Aquilia:
Wolfstar:
Democratic Donkeys:
Against.
Click to expand...
Not voting, but I would have to agree. This repeal has turned into the "bash Bitely hour" and has become very sickening. I do hope Ele takes a stance against the witch hunt and votes against this just to prove a point.
Click to expand...
Ummm. Bitely drafted a bad piece of legislation, then spent a lot of money to ensure the bill passed, then tried it again when the repeal came up and then was found to have broken multiple rules for NS and got booted from the WA?

I think it's perfectly understandable to "bash Bitely" given the behaviour.


And vote for the repeal btw
Click to expand...
No. It really isn't.
 
Wolfstar:
New Aquilia:
Wolfstar:
Democratic Donkeys:
Against.
Click to expand...
Not voting, but I would have to agree. This repeal has turned into the "bash Bitely hour" and has become very sickening. I do hope Ele takes a stance against the witch hunt and votes against this just to prove a point.
Click to expand...
Ummm. Bitely drafted a bad piece of legislation, then spent a lot of money to ensure the bill passed, then tried it again when the repeal came up and then was found to have broken multiple rules for NS and got booted from the WA?

I think it's perfectly understandable to "bash Bitely" given the behaviour.


And vote for the repeal btw
Click to expand...
No. It really isn't.
Click to expand...
So you rather ignore the actual facts involved in the case? Like how the WSA resolution the first time?

I'll stick to common sense thanks.
 
The General Assembly resolution Repeal "World Space Administration" was passed 10,051 votes to 3,432.

Voting on this resolution has ended.

Thanks to those nations who cast their votes. Your participation is a great help to the region.

This topic has been locked and sent to the Archives for safekeeping. If you would like this topic to be re-opened for further discussion, please contact the WA Delegate, a Global Moderator, or an Administrator for assistance. Thank you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top