[GA - AT VOTE] Repeal "Land Reclamation Regulation"

Fachu

Minister
-
-
Pronouns
He/Him
TNP Nation
RemiorKami
ga.jpg

Repeal "Land Reclamation Regulation"
Category: Repeal | GA#526
Proposed by: Tinhampton | Onsite Topic
Replacement: None​

Noting that Article 4 of GA#526 requires member states "to conduct impact studies to determine if proceeding with land reclamation will not violate" its provisions, even though Article 1b defines an impact study as "an independent survey conducted to determine the potential ecological impacts of land reclamation,"

Deducing that member states (unlike private enterprises) are completely prohibited from embarking on land reclamation under GA#526, given that they cannot conduct "an independent survey" of the "potential ecological impacts" of their own projects,

Concerned that GA#526 requires that member states submit the results of their Article 4 impact studies to the Environmental Survey of the World Assembly (ESWA) to determine if the land reclamation projects in question should receive a permit, that ESWA grant permits only to land reclamation projects that comply with GA#526's provisions (or where not granting them would "severely imperil the health of a nation’s population" or harm the environment more than granting them would), and that no land reclamation may commence without an ESWA permit,

Believing that individual member states - not ESWA - are best placed to determine whether any land reclamation planned within their jurisdiction complies with international law (never mind whether it offers better health or environmental benefits than doing nothing), and to grant or deny permits accordingly, and

Convinced that the establishment of an international bureaucracy to approve or reject all proposed land reclamation projects in member states is not a more worthy, needly or timely goal of this body than (for example) requiring member states to outlaw torture or take action against racial discrimination...

The General Assembly hereby repeals GA#526 "Land Reclamation Regulation."
Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations, NPA personnel, and those on NPA deployments will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote. If you are on an NPA deployment without being formally registered as an NPA member, name your deployed nation in your vote.

Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!

ForAgainstAbstainPresent
0401
 
Last edited:
Information For Voters

Vote AGAINST Repeal "Land Reclamation Regulation”.

Overview
This proposal attempts to repeal GA#526. It begins by pointing out a potential contradiction within the proposal, as member-states may not be able to conduct independent surveys of their own projects. Moreover, the proposal states that no member-state may continue on a land reclamation project without an ESWA (Environmental Survey of the World Assembly) permit, restricting member-states. The proposal finalizes its argument by stating that member-states should have the authority to determine their land reclamation projects.

Recommendation
Whilst the target resolution is certainly not perfect, and is almost certainly deserving of a repeal, we cannot currently support this effort. For one, the proposal focuses on some supposed loopholes, that are not actually major problems. A member-state may very well be able to, within the scope of the word “conduct”, direct an independent survey, making that claimed loophole dubious at best. Furthermore, the idea that member-states should be left to handle environmental issues all by themselves, fully at their own will, with no international support or regulation, is a dangerous precedent pushed by the “Believing” clause, and a sentiment that should not be supported.

Therefore, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote AGAINST “Repeal 'Land Reclamation Regulation'”.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top