[SC - PASSED] Commend Emiline

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hulldom

Hulldom

Winter Kingdom
-
Pronouns
He/Him/His
TNP Nation
Boston Castle
Discord
seathestarlesssky
sc.jpg

Commend Emiline
Category: Commendation | Target: Emiline
Proposed by: Free Azell, Co-authored by: DiRito-Opilis and Lesser Velutaria | Onsite Topic​

The Security Council,

Introducing Emiline as a nation whose world-building and foreign affairs work in Anteria and abroad has had a lasting effect on the greater world community;

Acknowledging that the government of Emiline controls that of Zhengan, the founder and protector of Anteria, one of the largest and most significant regions in the world which contains over 120 World Assembly member nations;

Recognizing that the government of Emiline also controls that of Prybourne, a nation whose seminal role in Anterian culture includes:
1. Helping to build its flourishing and highly-regarded community, which allows for nations to share in detail their history, culture, and language development, through events such as weekly theme topics which promote cultural exchange within the region,
2. Working diligently to help to spread the immense and unique world of Anteria lore, ensuring that Anteria stands out as a unique region that attracts a variety of nations with many different cultures and languages;
3. Creating the Sumo Club, in which they host events, discussions, and watch parties to bring more attention to the sport of Sumo Wrestling, attracting interest from many regions and adding immense value to their cultural make-up;

Further recognizing Emiline’s extensive efforts towards the administration of Anteria and the management of its foreign affairs, such as:
1. Establishing Anteria’s declarations of friendship with the Augustin Alliance (AA) and Karma, expanding its cultural and World Assembly cooperation with them;
2. Expanding Anteria’s reach and influence in the world by establishing an embassy with Lazarus, and most recently negotiating a Declaration of Friendship treaty with The West Pacific in the areas of defense, culture, and World Assembly cooperation, solidifying a strong relationship built over several years;
3. Authoring Anteria’s constitutions that establish the basic foundation for the region, in addition to creating a comprehensive guide for other regions on how to effectively construct their own;
4. Leading the recruiting efforts in Anteria to help it grow into the large region it is today and providing recruiting support through various methods, with one campaign netting over 500 nations;
5. Constantly promoting a strong, active, and security-focused World Assembly presence in the region, which now ranks 16th in the world for most average endorsements and is the 4th most powerful region in the United Regions Alliance (URA) voting bloc;

Applauding Emiline’s introduction of Anteria as a founding member of the URA, a move which no doubt granted the URA widespread legitimacy and recognition, and brought Anteria into the forefront as a leader in inter-regional politics and exposure in the great realms of the world stage;

Desiring to celebrate Emiline’s exemplary long-term success in helping to recruit new and diverse regions to the URA as its Deputy Director of Recruitment, such as the multilingual region of Portugal, aiding in the increase of the size and strength of the URA;

Exuberant at Emira Emi of Emiline’s ongoing service as an Administrator in the Augustin Alliance, where they oversee its day-to-day operations by implementing strong central planning, promoting unity between the AA's member regions, and coordinating the AA's goals, helping to perpetuate the growth of the AA, its influence and World Assembly population even during the most challenging periods;

Impressed at Emiline's instrumental role in ensuring the AA's success and safety during the first five editions of the annual nuclear conflict known to the world as N-Day, where it captured three first-place and one third-place award in total. In addition to avoiding all radiation during the fourth N-Day, Emiline also constructed a strong and mutually beneficial strategic bond between the AA and Anteria, as well as acting as an important mediator between the AA and other regions;

Convinced that Emiline's work to further culture, creativity, constructive regional growth, and common-sense foreign policy throughout the world deserves to be recognized with the greatest award this Assembly can bestow upon a nation;

Hereby commends Emiline;
Click to expand...
Note: Only votes from TNP WA nations and NPA personnel will be counted. If you do not meet these requirements, please add (non-WA) or something of that effect to your vote.
Voting Instructions:
  • Vote For if you want the Delegate to vote For the resolution.
  • Vote Against if you want the Delegate to vote Against the resolution.
  • Vote Abstain if you want the Delegate to abstain from voting on this resolution.
  • Vote Present if you are personally abstaining from this vote.
Detailed opinions with your vote are appreciated and encouraged!

ForAgainstAbstainPresent
31003

"Commend Emiline" has passed 9,510 votes (59.0%) to 6,600 (41.0%).
 
Last edited:
IFV
Overview
The proposal at vote seeks to commend the nation of Emiline for their efforts to build up Anteria as its founder, as well as their service in the United Regions Alliance (URA) and the Augustin Alliance (AA). It cites their work to create an alluring culture, increase its population, establish its constitutional laws, expand its diplomatic connections and increase World Assembly engagement in Anteria, as well as the moderating presence they've exerted there since the region's beginning. It also brings up their contributions as an influential founding member of the URA, where they brought legitimacy and interest to its initial state and helped recruit new regions to its ranks. Finally, their ongoing tenure as an Administrator in AA is brought up, where they coordinate the day-to-day operations of the behemoth coalition and its member regions and helped it gain international recognition by leading it to multiple victories in annual N-Days.

Recommendation:
While a convincing enough case can be built that the nominee is worthy of recognition from this august chamber, this proposal doesn't do them justice. It's haphazardly written, poorly formatted, contains ill-advised choices of wording and is in general of a mediocre quality. This doesn't live up to the high standards the Security Council prides itself on having and should be unilaterally rejected until it reaches an acceptable stage of quality where we can comfortably recommend for commending this arguably deserving nation.

For the above reasons, the Ministry of World Assembly Affairs recommends a vote Against on the Security Council at-vote, "Commend Emiline".

This IFV Recommendation was written in collaboration with our World Assembly Legislative League partners.
Our Voting Recommendation Dispatch--Please Upvote!
 
Last edited:
Against (Non-WA).
As I said in WALL, the nominee very well may be commendable, but the proposal in question simply doesn't make a good enough case to support that argument, and the format is very wonky. Additionally, I've been told by one of my constituents in Euro that as a member of the Augustin Alliance, the nominee has been partially responsible for hostile and distasteful behavior towards a variety of regions, including Thaecia, with which Euro is aligned.
 
For (Non-WA)
Myself being someone who has worked with the above said Nominee directly/Indirectly, also someone who knows the above said Nominee is commendable and has also seen the drafting from its beggining. I would like to bring up some counterstatements for the claim brought up by Gem.

It has to be noted that Emiline has nothing to do with the hostilities between August and Thaecia. It was to be honest, more like an issue between August and Thaecia and not the whole Alliance and Thaecia. Emiline has been a long time member of the Augustin Alliance, but regarding the hostilities I'm not sure if they were involved. One of the latest controversies regarding the alliance was the August - Andurse (Thaecia) hostility. Many of you must have seen what happened in the NS Forums regarding it. It was never a planned hostility and was mostly regarding opinions of the alliance's founder.

As Gem said, the nominee is someone who's commendable. But you should take it to consideration that whatever commendation draft is brought up everything would have the mention of Emiline's contribution to Augustin Alliance.
 
This proposal has achieved the requisite approvals to enter the formal queue. Barring it being withdrawn or marked illegal, it will proceed to a vote at either Minor Update today or Saturday’s Minor Update, depending on whether “On Raider Unity” can come back into quorum.
 
Present

It seems like that Emi’s involvement in the Thaecia thing was made up, yet it also seems like the contributions outlined in the proposal only benefit the Augustin Alliance, and not NS as a whole.
 
"Commend Emiline" has passed 9,510 votes (59.0%) to 6,600 (41.0%). This is author Free Azell (Ellenburg) and co-author Lesser Velutaria's 1st Security Council Resolution authored and co-author DiRito-Opolis's 2nd Security Council Resolution authored.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top