August 19, 2023
Vice Delegate Report
By now everyone knows what's happened within the last week or so. Once again, for the second time this year, our Delegate has resigned and necessitated the Vice Delegate to step up and serve as Acting Delegate. That means that once more, the duties of Vice Delegate fall to me as the next in the LoS. It's only fair I do this now, since the last couple of times it would have fallen on me, Siwale stepped up because I always seem to be on the Court when I am needed in this role. Maybe I should stop running for Justice, who knows.
I will hold down the fort, no worries there. There's a lot of work to do that's similar to what happens in a new term, but it's happening at the same time the existing term is also starting to wind down, and we have to start looking at the next election. As a result, I can't promise any movement on Chipoli's old plans. We are interested in bumping the endorsement numbers best that we can, so there may be some additional public outreach from me and the SC in the near future, but as for actions from this office, those will be likely limited to basic housekeeping, monitoring SC threads, VD checks, etc.
As is our new tradition, I have posted the most recent snapshot of endorsement levels available (this one is from roughly 24 hours ago). It is unfortunately more positive than current reality, as the Acting Delegate's current endorsement count is now 885 while mine is 867. We knew that the frontier update would do a number on us, but our mid-term transition cost us close to 100 endorsements all at once. I suspect that gap would have been less even with Gorundu still in place, but this shows that we cannot be complacent with endotarting. Endorsements shed fast these days, and if we want to get anywhere close to where we used to be, we have to keep at it. I can only ask so much of those of you who actually bother to keep up with this, but some casual encouragement of your friends on the RMB certainly couldn't hurt. I don't want to come off as overly doom and gloom here though, compared to the other feeders we're still doing really well. TSP currently has 587 endorsements on their delegate. TEP has 494, TWP has 437, and NPO has 406. The next highest endorsement count below ours is TCB's at 632. The fact that we can still shoot for 900 and stay somewhere in our historic low-range is worth at the very least a pat on the back and should make you feel some assurance. But if this is our high zone, we shouldn't be surprised if we slip even further at times. Just part of getting used to the new reality, but I think we're still pretty good at this endorsement thing.
I would be remiss if I did not remark on current events in the RA which relate to this office. There is a proposal on amending the law around citizenship which would make it possible for nations to be barred from citizenship based on the region they come from, if the region is designated to be one that merits such treatment. My contribution to the discussion, until earlier today/yesterday, was to propose simply adding nations from regions that have diplomatic restrictions placed on them to the list of people the Vice Delegate automatically rejects. This seemed simple and cleaner, and sidestepped the whole vote on restricting citizenship directly thing. Since the VD would have to deny them in either version of the proposal, it didn't seem to matter since the RA would have the final say on it regardless. I recognize now that this notion was misguided on my part. I can speak for many members of the Security Council, as well as myself, when I say that generally, we do not wish to make it a common occurrence for people to be barred from citizenship in The North Pacific. I do not subscribe to the notion that the Vice Delegate rejecting someone is automatically an affront to democracy or risking a fall down a slippery slope, because the Vice Delegate cannot ever unilaterally stop someone from becoming a citizen, only the RA backing him up can do that. However, I have always believed that it should be an uncommon occurrence. I believe that restricted regions will not lend themselves to many applicants who would need to be rejected by the Vice Delegate, but the fact is, that possibility is far easier to happen than any of the others currently on the list of people the Vice Delegate would reject. And worse, that category of nation is the most nebulous and potentially flimsy of causes. While we hope restricted regions would be rare and applicants from them rarer still, we still would be in the position of deciding whether or not to turn people away simply because of the region they come from and nothing else. My gut tells me a lot of applicants from such regions would be passed by the RA if the only thing the VD can say is "I was forced to reject them, so what do you want to do?" Therefore, if we do consider taking this step and opening up this type of scenario in future citizenship debates, I accept that a high threshold for declaring regions to be restricted in this way is advisable. We should continue to be very careful in how we restrict citizenship, and very deliberate with those we target. The more discussion and the more consensus we get on it, the better. It should continue to be rare and significant when someone is rejected by the Vice Delegate, and the RA should always be the final arbiter on whether or not the rejection passes muster.
As always, this office is open for question and comment, and any assistance I can provide, including related to questions about the SC or any of its business. I will endeavor to make these reports weekly, or at least often enough to impart important information. And if I may, I would encourage any of you interested in this side of regional governance to inquire and give it a try. Even if you get turned away or don't win an election, the process can be a good learning opportunity, and you may just get a shot like our last few Vice Delegates. Whether the possibility of having to step all the way up to Acting Vice Delegate or Delegate is appealing or not as a long-shot outcome is appealing to you or not is up to you to decide, but like any part of NS, we can always use new blood to keep us fresh and current.
-Pallaith